New York Knicks outlook after Carmelo trade

It was reported earlier today that the New York Knicks have traded Carmelo Anthony to the Oklahoma City Thunder. In return, the Knicks received C Enes Kanter, SF Doug McDermott and the Chicago Bulls’ 2018 Second Round Pick.

2017 Outlook

Does this make the Knicks better for the upcoming season? Heck, no. The Eastern Conference is extremely weak this year. Therefore, I gave the Knicks a slight chance of making the playoffs as the 8th seed with Carmelo on the team. However, I no give them no chance of making the playoffs.

Their starting lineup should look something like this:

PG: Ramon Sessions
SG: Courtney Lee
SF: Tim Hardaway Jr.
PF: Kristaps Porzingis
C: Enes Kanter

I do like Willy Hernangomez, but I like pairing up Porzingis with Kanter better. Ramon Sessions will most likely be the starting point guard to begin the season, but as the season goes on I think Frank Ntilikina will take over. The Knicks should finish at either 13-15 this season in the East. It will be them, the Brooklyn Nets and Chicago Bulls fighting it out for the worst in the East.

Future Implications

For future reasons, I do actually like this trade for the Knicks. For you stubborn Knicks fans out there, get it through your head we were not bringing in that much for Melo. He is still an elite scorer, but besides that he does not do anything else well. On top of that, he is on the decline of his career and owed a ton of money.

Any first round pick the Knicks would have received from him would most likely have been in the 25-30 range of the first round. Instead, they received the Bulls’ second round pick that will be in the 31-34 range at the beginning of the second round. The Knicks were find with this pick because of the talent they received back in Enes Kanter. The Knicks were not getting a player of his caliber from any other team. They also received a decent bench player in Doug McDermott.

First let us take a look at the contracts that were exchanged. Carmelo Anthony is owed $53 million over the next two years, while Enes Kanter and Doug McDermott are owed a combined $44 million over the same span. On top of that, Enes Kanter has a player option that can opt out of. If he does opt out, the Knicks can still re-sign him and I think he will be worth less money than Carmelo would be owed. He also would be on the rise, while Melo’s talents are falling.

The Knicks can now say they have a power forward and center for their future, hopefully a point guard as well. A duo of Kristaps Porzingis and Enes Kanter down low may be one of the best front court duos in the league. Let’s take a quick look at the duos who are POSSIBLY better than them right now:

Boston Celtics: Marcus Morris, Al Horford
Cavaliers: Kevin Love, Tristan Thompson
Nuggets: Paul Millsap, Nikola Jokic
Clippers: Blake Griffin, DeAndre Jordan
Pelicans: Anthony Davis, DeMarcus Cousins
Wizards: Markieff Morris, Marcin Gortat
Raptors: Serge Ibaka, Jonas Valanciunas

I think most of those are debatable besides the Clippers, Nuggets and Pelicans. Even then, Kanter and Kristaps are younger than all of them. Being able to build around something like that is key for a young team. If Frank Ntilikina pans out then they are set at point guard as well. So, now you have a Point Guard, Power Forward and Center for your future. The Knicks will likely have a top five pick this year too. They can add another young, key piece to their rebuild through the draft. You are looking at four starters who will be 26 years or younger come the 2018 NBA season.

Can this lead them to luring a superstar NBA free agent to New York? Now that Phil Jackson is out of town, I would say it is definitely possible. The Garden is the mecca of sports, so many iconic moments have happened there. Why wouldn’t an NBA star want to help bring a champion to NYC? They would be a legend in the greatest city in the world.

Over the next two years there are plenty of superstars who will be free agents. LeBron James, Chris Paul, DeMarcus Cousins, Russell Westbrook, Kevin Durant and Klay Thompson are a few. Can the Knicks bring one of these stars to New York? Maybe. Only time will tell. However, as a Knicks fan, I am very happy with the direction this team is headed. Carmelo will definitely be missed as he has been the only bright spot for this franchise over the last few years, but it was time to move on. I am happy he was traded to a contender and I hope he can win himself a title. I wish nothing, but the best for Carmelo. #StayMe7o


Published by

Nicholas LoPrinzi

I'm a washed up D3 college baseball player who is pursuing their MBA in Accounting. I love baseball, basketball, and football; while rooting for the New York Mets, New York Knicks, and New York Giants. Most of the time it is full of misery. I have recently found a passion for writing about sports. I have posted a few articles for Last Word on Sports and I have now created my own website ( You can check out my articles there and also follow the twitter account @_thesportstalk.

5 thoughts on “New York Knicks outlook after Carmelo trade”

  1. Kanter is a stiff. He’s on the upswing? how do you figure? His falling points per game? The fact that at 6’11” he averages less than a half blocked shot a game? not to mention he’ll be the highest paid Knick this year (yup, even more than Noah) who will only take minutes from Hernangomez and O’Quinn both of whom are familiar with KP and, especially in Hernangomez case, a far superior player


  2. Please, save the analytical s for your fantasy team. Hernangomez played less minutes per game and had more rebounds blocked shots and assists per game. Plus he has played with KP for awhile now. O’Quinn is the only guy the Knicks have who resembles an enforcer. Kantner is only going to siphon off minutes from those guys.


    1. I didn’t know analytics are fantasy sports now .. Seems like the stats you are talking about are, but Kanter also played with Russ who man handled the ball .. If you watched basketball you would know from a pure talent standpoint Kanter is better than any Center we have


      1. I’ve probably been watching Basketball since before you were born. You must live in Oklahoma. Hernangomez has better footwork, is a better shooter, and most importantly, has a good chemistry with KP. And will not count nearly 18 million in cap space. I’ve seen this before…. Mark Jackson got run out of town because of his defense. Bernard King was cut loose because he’d never fully recover from his injury Xavier McDaniel was too volatile.. You keep those guys on the Knicks and Patrick has rings


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s